Mirror’s Edge: Trial and Error

Unlike most people who bought Mirror’s Edge when it was first released, I knew it was not going to be spectacular. Still, I decided to try it out because jumping around rooftops Parkour style it looked vaguely fun to me. Sadly the game has as much to do with actual Parkour as Super Mario has to do with plumbing. If you watch the pro’s do their rooftop running shtick on Youtube you will notice one thing: they never stop. The whole fucking thing is one fluid motion. They just bounce off the available terrain features and keep going, using anything and everything to their advantage. The videos have this uninhibited free flow feel to them. I’m sure a lot of them are rehearsed and practiced beforehand but I sort of feel that a Parkour game should be all about the crazy ass running, vaulting, jumping, rolling and etc…

People always ask how can they make precision jumps in a FPS without being able to see their feet. In ME you can see your feet. It does not help though.

Mirror’s Edge certainly has the moves but lacks the feel of these videos. Each level is essentially a maze with only one possible path through it. In most cases the game maps it out for you by coloring certain terrain features red to indicate you should jump or grab on to them. Sometimes it doesn’t though, and that’s usually where you make a bad jump and die. The whole experience can be summarized like this:

  1. Jump, jump, fall to your death…
  2. Jump, jump, wall run, fall to your death
  3. Jump, jump, wall run, jump, get shot by a guard
  4. Jump, jump, wall run, jump, slide, right mouse button to disarm, jump, fall to your death

That is pretty much the whole game. If you press the jump button a second to early, you die. If you press it to late, you die. If you are at a wrong angle when you jump, you die. And sometimes you die because it is not completely clear as to what you should do. For example, sometimes a ledge seems to be close enough to just jump towards it. But if the designers wanted you to wall run to that edge, they will place it just inches out of reach instead. On the other hand if you wall run instead of just jumping, it is easy to overshoot the platform and fall. Other times you die because you are on some ledge and it is not entirely clear where you should jump next. There might be rooftops and platform all around you but only one of them can be accessed – and it is usually the one directly above your head (and as Valve designers found out, players hardly ever look up).

Visually the cityscape in this game is stunning even if a little sterile.

So the whole free-flow of Parkour is gone – unless you have already memorized the whole level and can do all the jumps with your eyes closed. The game about crazy, frantic acrobatic rooftop running actively discourages you from doing anything crazy or unplanned. After each jump you are expected to stop to make sure you are aligned just right for the next jump. If you try to wing it, you will be punished. The terrain is your #1 enemy in this game – which is ass backwards to me. You are this limber, ultra-athletic chick who is chased by corporate cops in full body armor. Terrain should be your best ally and your main advantage. And yet you usually need to take out all the enemies in the area before you even consider making some of the difficult jumps, because if you don’t they will shoot you down in mid air. And even if they don’t their bullets will nudge you millimeters off course and make your jump fail.

Even tiny tweaks to the game play would make a huge improvement – for example making your character a bit more aware of the surroundings. Make her automatically stop at an edge of the roof to prevent accidental fall. Make her automatically grab the ledge when the player accidentally walked off the platform while trying to set up a jump. Detect that the player is missing a jump by a half an inch, and just make it happen. Strategically place flag poles and platforms the character could auto-grab after missing a big jump that was shown to be tricky in the testing phase. Furthermore designing several paths through the level instead of a single one would go a long way. As it is right now the game is almost painfully linear.

The fact you can see your hands and feet as you run. Sometimes I get tired of playing the disembodied hand with gun.

In my mind, the game should encourage the player to do spectacular jumps and make them easy and relatively risk free – focusing on making the guards and the police the main threat. The game should be full of “Holly shit, I can’t believe I just did this!” moments rather than a series of timed jumps.

The combat is an awful mess as well. First off, you are told you should try to run away from cops whenever possible – and surely enough your first encounters with law enforcement pit you against immortal swat teams with machine guns. Shortly after that however you find yourself in a position when you have to take out a whole squad before you are able to movie on. That is also the point at which you realize that the following actions have the exact same effect on your enemy:

  1. Punching him in the face
  2. Hitting him with a running jump kick
  3. Sliding across the floor and kicking him in the groin
  4. Running up the wall, and hitting him with a spinning roundhouse kick in the face

Each of these attacks will make your opponent stagger, and take a step back – giving you just enough time to recover from your attack, but not enough to gain any advantage. However there is another way. If you get in your opponent’s face, they will stop shooting (for some odd reason) and try to pistol-whip you or hit you with the butt of their rifle. As they do that, their weapon will flash red for a fraction of a second. If you manage to press the right mouse button while it’s red, you will perform an instant disarm-and-auto-kill move. In other words, combat is basically a quick-time event.

You will be seeing a lot of this in your game. Every time you miss a disarm move actually.

You would think that a Parkour styled game would let you knock your opponents down just by running into them, or do crazy stunts like sliding in between their legs, using their chests and shoulders as springboards and etc. They should be ridiculously hard to kill, but easy to throw, push down (applying leverage or using your velocity) or outmaneuver by a small and agile runner. Combat should be about temporarily buying yourself time and increasing distance between you and your pursuers – not about taking down fully armed swat teams in riot gear with your bare hands. But alas, that’s precisely what this game is about.

These guys can't be killed. You know because they don't glow red.

Granted, the running and jumping part can be fun – especially when you really hit an extended stretch of the game where you don’t die. My favorite parts were those rare spots in the game where you had a bit of open terrain to cover and a wide margin for errors, and clear goal in sight. So you could really pick up speed, and just enjoy the acrobatics without stopping every minute and playing “spot the next red thing”.

Mirrors’ Edge has a crappy game play, but it the story is even worse. But I’ll leave that discussion for another time.

This entry was posted in video games and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Mirror’s Edge: Trial and Error

  1. Liudvikas LITHUANIA Mozilla Firefox Ubuntu Linux says:

    Actually I liked Mirrors edge.
    Story might not be very deep, but it’s just enough.
    Gameplay might be based on trial and error and I agree that more fluid movement might be better, but there’s only a few points where you’ve got to position yourself perfectly. I almost
    always just ran and ran without stop, except for that occasional fall.

    And their making a sequel, so we’ll see how they improve it.

    Reply  |  Quote
  2. Zel FRANCE Mozilla Firefox Windows Terminalist says:

    I think the heroine does a ledge grabbing move if you’re too short, sometimes… It might depend on the game’s difficulty, I think I played it on Easy. Combat was not hard because you can use the guns you recover to shoot people down and health regeneration makes you immortal if you’re a little bit careful. You need to do the quick time event to get the first gun and then it’s FPS time. Most of my death were due to the precision jumping, especially when sliding.

    The game is quite short, but you can run Time Attack challenges if you enjoy this sort of things. I do remember having the impression there were multiple paths to objectives, but I played this quite a while ago and honestly don’t remember the actual levels so well.

    Reply  |  Quote
  3. IceBrain PORTUGAL Mozilla Firefox Linux Terminalist says:

    Well, then you won’t like Canabalt

    Reply  |  Quote
  4. Luke Maciak UNITED STATES Mozilla Firefox Linux Terminalist says:

    @ Liudvikas:

    Yeah, the game is fun when you can just run uninterrupted. Eventually though you fall off the edge or run into a large group of enemies and then the fun is over. Or the game goes into a cut-scene and you just sit there wondering who the hell approved this script in the fist place. :)

    @ Zel:

    Well, you only get couple of shots with each gun, so in most cases you have to perform several disarms one after another.

    Also as far as I could tell 99% of the time there was only one correct way to beat the level. There is an illusion of choice sometimes but it is just that: an illusion.

    Reply  |  Quote
  5. JKjoker ARGENTINA Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    i kind of liked some parts of mirror’s edge (mostly the same as you, the parts where you can pick up speed and just run without dying), ME is at its best when it feels like the ending of the matrix when Neo is running like crazy for the phone and agents appear everywhere.

    i liked the tension of seeing the cops following you but it really sucks when you get stuck looking for the next red thing and they reach you

    while the trial and error gameplay can get a bit frustration i hated the indoor bits much more, they are dull, you dont even get a choice between jumping a fence or running around it and they have the highest probability of getting you lost (i remember a particularly bad part when i was stuck inside a mall with respawning cops with machine-guns and couldnt find the not-red exit, that wasnt fun)

    Reply  |  Quote
  6. Luke Maciak UNITED STATES Mozilla Firefox Windows Terminalist says:

    @ JKjoker:

    Ah, yes! I got lost int that mall too. I also got lost on the stupid boat in couple of places. But the absolutely worst level design was that large hall with the columns and walkways near the point where you get the sniper gun. There was no red anywhere and it was like a puzzle – what can you jump at or wall run to. I probably died like 50 times there before I figured out where exactly did I need to go.

    Reply  |  Quote
  7. k00pa FINLAND Mozilla Firefox Windows Terminalist says:

    I have to disagree.

    Mirrors edge is good game. Got it from sale on steam for about 2e, but I would not pay anything above 20e for this game.

    I love the graphics of this game… Blooom…. The end music is also awesome.

    But yeah, there is lot of stuff to improve.

    Reply  |  Quote
  8. JKjoker ARGENTINA Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    ah yes i remember that boat i got stuck twice there, i didnt have as much trouble getting to the sniper as i had trying to snipe the thing they tell you to snipe, the game kept telling me i did it wrong, i had no idea wth was going on and every time you “do it wrong” you have to run part of the way to the sniper again

    about the story, i think this game is a great example of “dude, you got your story all over my gameplay”, its completely irrelevant, adds nothing, you dont care about anyone, makes little sense and it just helps to bring the game down altogether, game devs need to learn that sometimes all you need to do is give the player a vague context and then let him/her have fun

    btw, i remember reading an article about the story “writer” Rhianna Pratchett where she said that they gave her the levels already finished and told her to write something to chain them into a story, no wonder it sucks, the fact all the games that i know RP wrote (Overlord 2 for example) are also crappy doesnt help

    Reply  |  Quote
  9. Luke Maciak UNITED STATES Mozilla Firefox Windows Terminalist says:

    @ k00pa:

    Yes, graphics are very nice, but that goes without saying. Most modern games look gorgeous. What I like is the art design – the stark colors, contrasts, etc. Very well done.

    On the other hand, I didn’t as much care for the cartoon cut scenes. Their style didn’t really fit the hyper-realism of the game IMHO. Not to mention that all of them could have been easily rendered using the engine itself.

    @ JKjoker:

    Oh wow. You never got lost in that huge room with the columns connected via concrete walkways and scaffoldings? I had no clue where to go because there was absolutely nothing red in that room.

    And yeah, the sniper thing was silly. It took me like 10 attempts to get it right, and even then it was mostly pure luck. The truck should have had a flashing red component or something – you know, like “aim here”.

    Also: how the hell do you make a game without actually having a story first? Wow!

    Reply  |  Quote

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *