Let’s have a serious talk about Gamer culture

I have been playing video games most of my life. It all started in middle school. I don’t exactly remember how old I was when one of my friends invited me to his house to check out his brand new Commodore 64 rig. What I remember was how it felt like. I was completely blown away. It felt like I was in a science fiction movie, because I have never actually used a “real” computer before that. All of a sudden I was siting in front of a programable machine that could do literally anything if you only knew how to issue the right orders. Naturally the only orders we knew how to issue were the ones that loaded and ran games, which is what we did. Not only were the cassette tapes filled to the brim with pirated games cheaper than a trip to the arcades. They were also trivial to copy and exchange. For the first time we had a potentially infinite number of games we could play at our own leisure.

Commodore 64

Some people started on Nintendo. I started on C64.

For the next two years I basically lived in his house glued to that machine. We have spent countless hours becoming experts at calibrating the cassette tape deck and accumulated a vast library of pirated games, half of which never actually loaded. Still, we had a lot of fun. Later another friend got an Amiga 500 and I was once again completely blown away by the sheer power and speed of that 16 bit gaming marvel and the sheer capacity of the 3.5 inch floppy disks it used as primary storage medium.

C64 Head Fit Program

Successfully loading a game using the C64 tape deck was a function of luck, stable platform and the time you put in cleaning calibrating the tape heads prior to the attempt.

It wasn’t until sixth or seventh grade when I finally got my own gaming rig. Unboxing the Amiga 600 was probably one of the happiest moments of my childhood. Finally I was able to play games I wanted on my own time. You could say that was the moment I became a “gamer” but that probably wouldn’t be accurate because there wasn’t such a thing yet back then. Just about everyone who owned a personal computer was to some degree a gamer, because that’s what the 8-bit and 16-bit rigs, which connected directly to a TV and shipped with a pair of Joysticks more often than with a mouse, were good at. Dedicated gaming consoles were still a few years off (at least in my corner of the woods) so me and my friends drew lines in the sand, and insulted each other over hardware platform choices our dads made based on what they could afford.

Amiga 600

Amiga 600: my first “gaming rig”

I don’t really think we had a “gaming community” when I was a kid, but rather a vague granular collective of various quarreling sub-groups, with distinct tastes, preferences and philosophies. These sub groups traditionally always disagreed about pretty much everything and constantly bickered over just about everything. As far as I’m concerned sense of fellowship and camaraderie among gamers did not arise until internet era. The first time I can remember gamers of all creeds standing together as one was during the brief moral panic over video game brutality about a decade ago. When Jack Thompson and is ilk took on video game industry we all put away our differences and united against the common enemy. I was there along side with my gaming brethren loudly proclaiming that video games do not make one violent, while at the same time screaming for Thompson’s head on a pike. The irony of that behavior escaped me back then, but it was possibly the first time I felt something akin to a “community” sense. It was “we the gamers” against the world.

Jack Thompson

I think this guy did more to solidify a unified, monolithic “gamer bro” identity that transcended platform, genre and age divides than anyone else.

Other than a common enemy we did not really have much in common. We didn’t even like the same games, and we were just beginning to have dialogs across the platform and genre divides. But most of us were young, middle class, nerdy young males. And so we built the community around our the stuff we had in common: our own toxic masculinity, our elitism and our persecution complexes. In absence of positive values, we defined ourselves in opposition against censorship, control and the mainstream which rejected our hobby. After our common enemies faded away, we let that noxious concoction boil and fester unchecked for a decade. The behavior we see today is a direct result of our failure to build and curate an inclusive, progressive community.

This is what it all really boils down to. Gaming culture was never anything but this weird, insular, xenophobic ghetto built around very toxic notions of masculinity and persecution complex. Games marketed at boys promoted and reinforced this hyper-machismo image, and gamers were seeking to embody it and so it went in an endless self-reinforcing circle. It is no accident that teenagers scream homophobic and gender slurs into their head-sets or brag about “raping” the opposing team in Call of Duty. It’s no accident that video game related message boards basically invented the “tits or gtfo” greeting. It is no accident that Anita Sarkesian could post feminist critiques of SF films, TV shows and novels without much harassment but the moment she started talking about video games, she instantly got death and rape threats. Because this community was not build around tolerance, acceptance of criticism or diversity. It was a fortress of solitude built by man-children to protect their toys from evil mainstream activists.

Face of Modern Gaming

Face of Modern Gaming

Lets face it, the gamer culture is toxic and the community is broken. It always has been like this, but we didn’t really see it clearly up until recently because we did not pay attention. We had our heads too far up our asses for that. There were always people who were criticizing the culture and trying to fix things from within and without but they were not being heard. We drowned them out.

But then the internet things happened and our boys club industry got disrupted.

In 2014, the industry has changed. We still think angry young men are the primary demographic for commercial video games — yet average software revenues from the commercial space have contracted massively year on year, with only a few sterling brands enjoying predictable success.

It’s clear that most of the people who drove those revenues in the past have grown up — either out of games, or into more fertile spaces, where small and diverse titles can flourish, where communities can quickly spring up around creativity, self-expression and mutual support, rather than consumerism. There are new audiences and new creators alike there. Traditional “gaming” is sloughing off, culturally and economically, like the carapace of a bug. (…)

Developers and writers alike want games about more things, and games by more people. We want — and we are getting, and will keep getting — tragicomedy, vignette, musicals, dream worlds, family tales, ethnographies, abstract art. We will get this, because we’re creating culture now. We are refusing to let anyone feel prohibited from participating.

Gamer isn’t just a dated demographic label that most people increasingly prefer not to use. Gamers are over. That’s why they’re so mad.

Video games have outgrown young white male nerds. They have went mainstream for real this time and no single group can lay claim to them anymore. It is time to let them go. If you love something, let it go! Let it flourish. Let it become the artistic medium we all want it to be.

For the last few days I’ve been trying to figure out the right words to what to say about the latest shit-storm of internet ugliness perpetuated by “gamers”. I don’t really want to re-cap all the stuff that has happened because it would take me all day, and there are better sources for that. To wit, Andrew Todd posted an excellent writeup of the situation few days ago. I highly recommend giving it a read if you need to catch up with the situation.

I still don’t have the right words but I feel compelled to say something about it. After all it is happening in my back yard and I feel partly responsible for this. I feel I contributed to this toxic culture of hatred and misogyny by complacency. I feel that I helped to cultivate these attitudes and helped to fan the flames by laughing at the wrong jokes, and not calling people out enough.

Consider this: a community which condones and celebrates rape jokes will eventually become a save haven for rapists. A community which turns a blind eye towards humor that involves casual racism, homophobia and transphobia becomes a safe place for bigot to share their opinions. That’s how it starts: with “harmless” jokes and an assumption that everyone is on the same page, and understands that the joke-tellers don’t actually mean the things they say. That they are just being “edgy”, that they are just pushing the envelope and etc. But here is a newsflash: there are people who are bigoted or rapey misogynists on the internet. They see these “funny jokes” not as a tongue in-cheek silliness but as a validation of their world views. They flock to your communities, they become your online buddies, your guildies, your Steam friends. And you won’t know they are terrible people because the your local custom is to for everyone pretend to be an absolute asshole even if they don’t mean it because this is the internet and you’ve got to have a thick skin to make it here. Because you worship this terrible, toxic masculine ideal of detached macho, “equal opportunity offender” who does not give a shit about anything or anyone as long as he gets his. And so your community slowly becomes this cesspit full of bigots and misogynists who think that d0xing someone and sending them rape threats is an appropriate response to a Youtube video criticizing a game they like.

Anita Sarkesian Harrasment

This is gamer community’s cool, measured and reasonable response to a video applying academic critique to the medium. (triger warning)

When your community is conditioned to routinely objectify women and treat them as prizes, objectives and decorations rather than individuals, then is it surprising that they eventually refuse to acknowledge women critics and developers as their peers? That women who want to help shaping and improving the video game industry from the inside are viewed as enemies and outsiders? When your community outright rejects concepts like “political correctness” is it any wonder it becomes abusive and shitty environment?

Like it or not, political correctness is just another way of saying “common human decency and empathy”. It is treating people that might not be exactly the same as you with the same respect and dignity as you would wish to be treated with. Not only does it keep your community inviting and open to everyone regardless of their sex, race or creed. It also keeps the absolute fucking monsters in check. Throwing it away is like rolling out a red carpet for sociopaths and miscreants itching to play out their sick power fantasies in front of a live audience.

Without rules, moderation and codes of conduct all communities tend to descend into anarchy as they grow. The end result of this process are sites like 4chan – the self-proclaimed cesspool of the internet. The myth of “self moderating” communities is false. The direct democracy of Reddit can actually be even worse because they give the community tools to silence any dissent and help to create an echo chamber effect only the most conservative and reductive opinions are heard. It allows the majority to get away with abuse while at the same time giving minorities no recurse other than to leave or hide. They are also cultural and social hubs for self identified gamers.

Popular gamer hangouts such as /r/gaming or /v/ that are honeypots for human shaped monsters who want to play out their sick and twisted fantasies in front of a live audience. And make no mistake – if you don’t say anything, if you turn a blind eye, laugh or wave off the abuse as “just internet things” you are part of that audience. You are enabler and a cheerleader to the abusers.

Trolls

This picture is pretty much literally the gamer culture: trolls being abusive assholes, and white dudes on the sidelines enabling, taking pictures and laughing their asses off at the carnage.

Think about this: what does the gamer community stand for? What are the values it espouses? Liking video games is not a community value or a moral stance in an of itself – it’s merely the circumstantial condition required for membership. Looking from the outside in, it does not look that good.

Is the gaming community welcoming to the outsiders? Fuck no. It is elitist, exclusionary. There is fierce gate keeping is in effect. It is not enough to love video games. It is not enough to be passionate about them. You have to like them in the “correct” way to be accepted. There are names for the people who want to participate in the community but are brutally rejected by it: casual gamers, “fake gamer girls”, etc..

Is the community take care of their own and ensure members are treated with respect? Fuck no. There is this notion that if you want to be a gamer, you have to develop a thick skin. You have to learn to take the abuse, because that’s what happens in gaming spaces. If you are hurt and offended you need to leave. If you don’t feel safe, you need to leave. The community believes that ones right to shout hurtful, hate filled slurs into the ether trumps your right to be treated as a human being.

Is there anything the community believes in? Like freedom of speech and artistic expression? Does it welcome constructive criticism? Fuck no! If you are the wrong kind of person and you criticize video games the wrong way you will face severe backlash and the community will try to silence you. Just look at what is happening to Anita Sarkesian for attempting to apply feminist theory to video game design the same way you would apply it to any other art form.

The gamer culture itself is also off limits and belong critique. If you don’t like the status quo, if you dare to say anything negative about the community you are a “social justice warrior” and therefore the enemy of the state. If you stand up for the abused, you become collateral damage.

These are the values of the gamer community: it’s pro abuse, pro hatred, and against social justice and political correctness. It is a community that will fight to death to protect the freedom of speech of racists, sexists and homophones while at the same time trying to silence legitimate academic feminist critiques. It is a community that prides itself for being apolitical while at the same time being more extremist and conservative on social issues than Fox could ever even dream to be. Let that sink in for a bit. Just think about what kind of people this sort of “culture” is attracting.

To be honest, I don’t want to be a gamer if those are gamer values and gamer culture. When I was a child, I did childish things, but as a grown ass man I don’t want to be a part of a community that condones d0xing and death threats. I don’t want to be a part of a “culture” which goes war against a female developer over what amounts to some insignificant gossip spread about her by a spurned ex. I don’t want to be a part of a group that makes women working in the industry feel unsafe to the point that their regular, day to day existence feels like desperate struggle for survival and make them leave in droves. It fucking kills me that we have already lost some prominent female developers and journalists over the gamer gate bullshit.

Compared to the harassment that happened in the past few weeks the whole “journalistic integrity” discussion seems petty and insignificant. How come we didn’t have a journalistic integrity crusade back when Jeff Gerstmann got canned for giving Kayne and Lynch a bad review score? Where was the self righteous anger and the burning ire back then? Everyone just shrugged and said: “See, I told you big companies do pay for review scores after all.” But somehow no one stepped up to make a full feature length documentary about that incident.

I seriously doubt I will convince anyone who has already thew their lot with the gamer gate hashtag to change their mind about this. But perhaps I can reach out to a few reasonable folks who did not get swept up in all the hatred yet. If, like me you are member of the “core” gamer demographic (meaning white, cis, hetero male), please realize we are have a social responsibility to fix this mess we created. We’re not gonna be able to fix it over night. We can’t go out and forcefully readjust the attitudes of all the “SJW conspiracy” nuts out there. But we can all try to affect change locally and within our means. Best place to start is with yourself. Examine your own behavior and think about your interactions with people in online communities and what kind of behaviors and attitudes your behavior encourages? Do you sometimes make off-color jokes? Do you upvote or otherwise reward hurtful or problematic posts? Can you do better?

Some time ago I went through several years worth reddit comment history and ended up nuking entire account in disgust. Not that this absolved me from past sins, but it did help me to realize I was part of the problem. That I came with my own baggage of hangups, insecurities and prejudices which made me behave like a complete shithead. That learned hyper masculine posturing behaviors are not conducive to building inclusive and welcoming communities. That freedom of speech is not the same as freedom to abuse and dehumanize others.

So start with yourself. Do some soul searching. Read what people who are different from you say about the community and their experience with it. Try to empathize with them. Try to be a better person, and by extension you will make the community a little bit less shitty for those in your immediate sphere of influence.

Beyond that, help other people be better. Help to shape and curate the kind of community you want to be proud of. Call out your friends, guildies or clan members when they are being sexist, racist, or shitty in general. Help to moderate communities where in which have leadership positions or where your voice can make a difference. If a large community like Fark can do it, then your local group should have no problem implementing a similar policy.

Reach out and help marginalized members of the community have their voices heard. There are plenty of things you can do to help. If you want to keep this identity and keep “gamer culture” alive then help to make it less shitty. Make it about something: about teaching, sharing and exploring the hobby. Banning abuse and making the community more open, inclusive and inviting to others is not going to destroy it. If anything it will make it better, healthier and more vibrant. An identity based on celebration of hatred, exclusion and abuse is not worth having.

We can either change what it means to be a gamer or kill this identity completely. We don’t need it anymore. Gaming is no longer a niche hobby. Being a nerd is no longer stigmatized the way it used to be. These days it is almost a fashion statement. Frankly, it may already be to late to salvage gaming as an identity. The events that transpired in August may have cemented the reputation of a gamer as an absolute worst kind of human being. To be honest, I have been hesitant to describe myself as a gamer for a while now, on the off chance that I might be associated with the kind of people who launch harassment campaigns against the women in the industry. Now I’m no longer hesitant. I ashamed. I don’t want anything to do with the people un-ironically posting to the gamer gate hashtag. So Im actually all for ending gamers and gaming communities.

If you need me, I’ll be over here sharpening my +3 double handed sword of social justice, writing critically about gender, race and social issues in gaming without an ounce of journalistic integrity, donating to cool patreons and playing with people who are not deranged sociopaths. Feel free to join me.

This entry was posted in video games. Bookmark the permalink.



15 Responses to Let’s have a serious talk about Gamer culture

  1. Robert UNITED STATES Safari Mac OS says:

    I was talking to a female gamer about this just the other day. (A Genius Bar worker at the local Apple store, where I was taking my MacBook Air in for a new screen. They’re everywhere, man.)

    See, I’m from an older tradition. When I was a teenager, a gamer was someone who played wargames or D&D. Computer gaming has, to me *always* been relatively mainstream. The violent gynophobia that’s so loud in the computer gaming community is completely baffling to me. It just didn’t used to be like that. There was certainly sexism among gamers in the late ’70s and early ’80s, but it was the casual, dismissive sort that was pretty common back then. “Girls aren’t into this sort of thing.” If a girl *was* interested, we didn’t try to keep her out, though; she was awesome!

    I think you’re right, Luke, that this is a response to the disintegration of the very concept of ‘gamer.’ The ‘hardcore’ gamers are becoming marginalized; computer games aren’t about them anymore. I’ve seen similar responses from other marginalized groups over the years. Amiga users back in the late ’80s as the platform faded out, OS/2 users 10 years later in the same situation. (I was an OS/2 user, and I switched to Windows the day I realized how hostile and whiny the community was becoming.)

    I think it’s a transitory problem, really. This generation of hardcore gamers is going to die out, or drift away from being hardcore gamers as they get, well, lives. The next generation, I think, will be much healthier. But in the meantime, it’s going to suck for a lot of people.

    Reply  |  Quote
  2. Luke Maciak UNITED STATES Google Chrome Linux Terminalist says:

    @ Robert:

    Yeah, fortunately for me I was never just a gamer. I always aimed to be sort of the jack of all trades when it came to nerdy stuff. I mean, yeah I was into computers and games, but I was also active in commic book and literary SF/fantasy fandoms, playing and paper RPG games, card games, tabletop miniature games. When I was in HS I was actually helping to moderate Farscape fan community and wrote fan fiction (don’t ask – it’s dead and burried and we will not talk about it :P). Fun fact – that community was created and ran by women and coincidentally it was probably the most fun and pleasant online experience I had. Even though the bulletin board we used has not existed for like a decade now, a number of us still keep in touch via social media.

    But yeah, the kids who only ever had vidya games to pin their identity to are probably taking the mainstreaming of the medium pretty hard. This is a pretty good article that talks about exactly this.

    Reply  |  Quote
  3. Gothmog UNITED STATES Google Chrome Windows Terminalist says:

    Aw, Luke. You need a *hug* man.
    I deeply feel your pain, frustration and disgust. I am also one of the c64-era gamers and am feeling more and more removed from the gaming-mainstream. I play almost EXCLUSIVELY small indy-ish games (NecroDancer!) lately and just cannot find the desire to play the trip-A games. Maybe we’re just getting old. This too shall pass. I’m trying to do my best to raise my 8 year old boy to be a responsible gamer- no trolling and just be nice, dammit. I have hopes for his generation- but the generation of game-bros that you’re describing- those that never had to load the Jumpman advanced levels on tape and wait 23 minutes for it to complete- have a core of impatience and ANGER to all those things that are not to their exact taste. I have nephews that are 25 and 16 that game and that describes them to a T. I find I can’t have a conversation with them about gaming without blurts of “I can’t stand X, or Y is just not for me”. It’s infuriating. Robert, I think you’ve hit it on the head that this GameBro-generation is having an identity-crisis. I hope they get over themselves and learn to be less of whiny bitchtrolls.

    Reply  |  Quote
  4. Etienne Google Chrome Mac OS says:

    @Robert
    What you say kind of reminds me of, and confirms what is being said in, this piece: http://www.doctornerdlove.com/2014/08/the-extinction-burst-of-gaming-c ulture/

    @Luke
    I am currently following a curricula of gaming and culture at ITU in copenhagen, so I have been following this “event” with great interest. And I have noticed that many of the more sane voices in this whole debate, are telling what amounts to the same story of the history of gaming culture. Which is essentially the one you told.

    Reply  |  Quote
  5. Luke Maciak UNITED STATES Google Chrome Mac OS Terminalist says:

    @ Gothmog:

    Internet hugs! :) And yeah, loading a game was serious business. Don’t move, don’t breathe and whatever you do don’t blink! It’s almost done! :P

    @ Etienne:

    Yeah, I would say this is a fascinating case for anyone studying gaming and gaming culture moving forward, except for the fact that actual people are getting hurt. :( But few years from now, when the flames go down and wounds are healed we will be able to revisit this in the form of a case study about the growing pains of gaming culture.

    Reply  |  Quote
  6. Etienne DENMARK Google Chrome Mac OS says:

    @Luke
    It was not my intention to come off as someone not taking it seriously or that I don’t appreciate the hurt that it is causing. I am continuously dumbfounded by the level of hostility and bile against women enacted by these people.
    And yes, a case study on this should probably first be done in a few years, when this has calmed down and has hopefully changed for the better.

    Reply  |  Quote
  7. TinyI UNITED KINGDOM Google Chrome Windows says:

    I was actually having a fb conversation about this a few weeks back when the whole Zoe Quinn thing was going crazy (what with all the hate sent towards her).

    The thing that really annoyed the hell out of me was when somebody commented with (and I quote verbatim) “The females in games thing comes straight from the consumers arguing about the stereotype of male gamers. It’s been going on since the 70’s because most games were war games and heavily attributed to men. There is no rape like culture lol.

    That kind of just made me realise how closed-minded, drone-like this community is – much like any that developed on the internet (IWC for example – Internet Wrestling Community) really. And then it finally hit me as to why. Consequences barely exist for these people playing the hate game. They don’t get banned, they don’t get called out, they don’t get thrown out of the community as such – people let it happen or they cheer it on. Because there’s no real concept of consequence on the internet, people just don’t care what they say and do or who they hurt in the process.

    Reply  |  Quote
  8. Luke Maciak UNITED STATES Google Chrome Linux Terminalist says:

    @ Etienne:

    Oh, no – I was not implying you were making light of it. I was just making an observation. :)

    @ TinyI:

    Zoe’s thing is still going, BTW. They never stopped harassing her, even after they started doing the whole gamer gate, journalism integrity thing, the harassment was still in full force. It turns out that Zoe has been hanging out in 4chan’s irc raid channel for weeks now logging their conversations. She started tweeting snippets of her logs over the weekend. She has evidence of people discussing how they hacked her servers, and how they d0xxed her, along with their IP addressees which she turned over to the police. So hopefully justice will be served. :)

    And yeah, it’s funny how whenever anyone speaks up about this they just deny them their voice. When women complain about representation, they are “evil misandrist feminazis” and “not real gamers”. When people of color complain about it, they are “playing the race card” and being overly sensitive or “reverse racist”. When white men complain about it they are “white knights” and “social justice warriors” who use the plight of the minorities to increase their social status somehow. Which is ironic considering how the gamer gate crown only ever seems to care about marginalized groups when they can usurp their voice and use it to discredit white, male critics.

    Reply  |  Quote
  9. TinyI Google Chrome Windows says:

    Luke Maciak wrote:

    @ TinyI:

    Zoe’s thing is still going, BTW. They never stopped harassing her, even after they started doing the whole gamer gate, journalism integrity thing, the harassment was still in full force. It turns out that Zoe has been hanging out in 4chan’s irc raid channel for weeks now logging their conversations. She started tweeting snippets of her logs over the weekend. She has evidence of people discussing how they hacked her servers, and how they d0xxed her, along with their IP addressees which she turned over to the police. So hopefully justice will be served. :)

    And yeah, it’s funny how whenever anyone speaks up about this they just deny them their voice. When women complain about representation, they are “evil misandrist feminazis” and “not real gamers”. When people of color complain about it, they are “playing the race card” and being overly sensitive or “reverse racist”. When white men complain about it they are “white knights” and “social justice warriors” who use the plight of the minorities to increase their social status somehow. Which is ironic considering how the gamer gate crown only ever seems to care about marginalized groups when they can usurp their voice and use it to discredit white, male critics.

    o? It was in the news more often then – thought it had curbed… shows how much I know unfortunately! It’s kind of really crappy how it’s still happening – I read more into the links that you provided and even the person who supposedly started the whole thing (Eron or something?) actually said it wasn’t true. Great.

    Hopefully justice gets served. But that still doesn’t deal with the people who jumped on the “hate Zoe” bandwagon en masse. Those bandwagon jumpers seem to be what fuels the extremes to do what they do – if they didn’t have their cheerleaders, they wouldn’t play the game I guess is what I’m trying to say.

    Ontop of that, this whole “gamer gate” seems to be a whole bunch of crap to silence people too according to the irc logs Zoe got. How messed up this whole thing is when you actually think about it kinda hurts… It’s like they want to find people to single out and victimise, one by one. Kinda like that film “The Purge” – where the gang of “elite education” kids wanted to beat and kill that homeless dude who turned out to be a war vet.

    Reply  |  Quote
  10. Pingback: A Rough Week For Gamers - Gameindustry.com WordPress

  11. Robert Safari Mac OS says:

    @ TinyI:

    Internet lynch mobs are not, unfortunately, exclusive to gaming culture. They’re a big deal, and they cut both ways.

    http://sjwar.blogspot.com/2014/02/3-outing-of-zathlazip-and-hounding-o f.html

    Reply  |  Quote
  12. Luke Maciak UNITED STATES Mozilla Firefox Windows Terminalist says:

    @ Robert:

    While I do not condone doxing, stalking or other forms of vigilante internet justice, that blog does not seem like a reliable resource. It’s basically “concern trolling, the book”. He is co-opting the vocabulary and concepts used by social movements in an attempt to discredit some imaginary, generalized social justice strawman that he made up in his mind. Plus I scrolled through some of his older posts, and ugh. :(

    But yeah – I get what you’re saying. This is a problem that is not unique to gaming community and I agree that bigots and hateful people also don’t deserve to receive death threats.

    Reply  |  Quote
  13. Robert Safari Mac OS says:

    @ Luke Maciak:

    I’m personally acquainted with one of the principals in one of the cases he talks about, and his overview is pretty accurate.

    But yeah, my point is mainly just that death threats and destroying someone’s life should still be socially unacceptable even if the person is a jerk. But it’s becoming uncomfortably acceptable.

    Reply  |  Quote
  14. Luke Maciak UNITED STATES Mozilla Firefox Windows Terminalist says:

    @ Robert:

    Yeah. I think it has a lot to do with the “greater internet fuckward” theorem – the perceived anonymity of the web makes people about 10 times more terrible than they would dare to be in real life. That and we have this weird distinction between “real life” and “the internet” which makes it seem like threats and hate campaigns less severe to the perpetrators (but not less frightening and unpleasant to their victims). And yeah, there are terrible people in just about every community.

    But, I really think this can be mitigated by properly managing your community and setting the right tone. Places like 4chan and reddit worship “freedom of speech” above all else and actively encourage trolling. As a result they enable harassment and attract the sort of shitty people who doxx and send death threats and this is where they go to recruit people for their “operations” and what not.

    If your message boards or discussion lists are moderated, there are clear codes of conduct and offenders are permanently banned and expelled then it is harder for the shitty people use your community as a platform for hateful stuff. Scale and the growth speed of the community will of course affect the ability to moderate things efficiently, but there are ways to deal with this too.

    I do have an issue with the blog guy’s rhetoric though. If I got his point right, he was essentially claiming that if you’re white and you call out another white person for doing something racist, you are literally usurping the right of POC to speak on this subject. That we should not be speaking on their behalf. But that’s insidious because it creates a toxic environment where racists get to control the discussion. White folks are told to be quiet because it does not involve them. Any POC who take offense and speak out make themselves targets for the racists and will likely be subject to tone policing, concern trolling and all the usual bullshit.

    I feel that it is partly my responsibility to ensure the communities where I am part of the majority demographic and where my voice counts, are open, friendly and welcoming for everyone. It’s like cleaning out our little frat house so that we can invite some guests without being ashamed at how filthy it has become due to people not paying attention to what they do or say.

    Reply  |  Quote
  15. @ Luke Maciak:

    For context, it might be worth noting that Will Shetterly was part of a kerfuffle still known in SF fandom as “Racefail ’09.” It wasn’t as bad as GamerGate in terms of sheer criminality, but did involve a fair number of “names” (both pro and fan) not acquitting themselves particularly well.

    IMO Shetterly’s a very good writer and well-meaning man whose particular personality & perspective (class-consciousness rather than feminist & other identity politics) made him incapable of accepting that he might be in the wrong. I gave up on closely following SF fandom in part because of RaceFail and other infighting; it’s genuinely sad to me that those divisions have only sharpened over the years.

    Reply  |  Quote

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *